Fueling the Paranoia

Wednesday, July 16, 2008

Fueling the Paranoia

Updated 07/16/2008 - 03:25 pm

Now one could marginalize this as "someone else who's bought into the mythos which our local Rabbi has created for himself," but it is instructive to digest:

"First, it’s important to note that we were at a friend’s house very close to the Hampton Syna­gogue, which was founded 18 years ago by Rabbi Marc Schneier and is thriving in a place and a situation where such success was consid­ered extremely unlikely. If you want to gain some insight into what an eclectic mix of modern Jew­ish men and women from very diverse back­grounds are doing these days, it’s worthwhile taking a look inside what Rabbi Schneier has built and de­vel­oped here in the Hamptons."

That is an excerpt from the July 11th "Hamp­tons Diary" entry of a "private blog" by Larry Gordon.

It's innocuous enough... until one gets to the part which reads:

"In Westhampton—quite a few years ahead of the others—there is talk of an eruv in town. Local residents don't like it, because—as the New York Times reported a few weeks ago—they are afraid the eruv will turn the Hamptons into another Five Towns. I don't see anything specifically wrong with that, but then again that's just my opinion."

Despite Mr. Gordon's qualifier, that alone should send Irene Barrett and her Christian Citizens' Coalition (née Westhampton Beach Alliance for the Separation of Church and State) into full-frothing mode!

On balance, it should be noted that an earlier entry, Hilary Larson's "Day Tripping Through the Hamptons," from August 17, 2006 states:

"The days when Jews were unwelcome in these WASPY precincts is long gone, and today large numbers of young Jewish families are settling the East End – especially East Hampton, Bridge­hampton and Westhampton. The hottest (free) ticket on Friday nights is the service at the Hampton Synagogue in Westhampton Beach, a formerly sleepy village that is becoming livelier each year, in large part due to the Manhattan-based Jewish community that has coalesced around this 16-year-old shul. Technically Ortho­dox, the Hampton Synagogue's laid-back, friend­ly services draw worshippers{sic} from across the spectrum."

And yes, this could also be dismissed as some­one else having bought into Rabbi Schneier's carefully-crafted "My Synagogue and my peeps are the ones who've resurrected Westhamp­ton Beach from its economic doldrums" message.

While I cannot cite it specifically¹ due to a total lack of familiarity with the Torah, I'm confident that those of the Jewish faith will comprehend the applicability of the Biblical synthesis:

"As ye sow, so shall ye reap."

Of course, it would come as no surprise to dis­cover that it originated in the Torah!

Note

¹.- Got it! It's from the King James Version of Galatians 6:7. "Be not deceived; God is not mocked: for whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he al­so reap." Now let's move on.

Comments

1. rburg said...

Rabbi Schneier was instrumental in moving to get Club Marakesh shut down. He was the one willing to take on the heavies. At least that is my recollection. Unfortunately, it took the Shane Daniels beating to bring it to conclusion.

Really? That is not my recollection at all, and I was there at that time. I fear that this is little more than more of the Rabbi's notorious self-agrandizement.
Dean

2. Ray Overton said...

I would think that someone as critical as you regarding others' compositions would know that the phrase you are refer{sic} to at the end of your blog should read "As ye sow, so shall ye reap." Also, you may also want to check your Biblical sources as I believe the closest version of that verse comes from the New Testament Book of Galatians

Well, Ray, you've absolutely nailed me on the "critical" of "others' compositions" part. But you're oddly off-base on the rest!

I'm not sure what you think you read, but a more careful reading on your part would reveal that "As ye sow, so shall ye reap" is precisely what it does state, and has from the beginning.

Furthermore, because I do take time to get it right, I spent 30 minutes or so trying to track the specific chapter and verse of the source via 'Net searches, and finally called a trust-worthy local church-going lady with a concordance at hand. She also came up with Galatians 6.7, but the language seems to have been changed. Therefore, rather than provide a specific citation, I very deliberately elected to refer to "Biblical synthesis."

But thanks for trying to keep me on my toes.
Dean

3. Ray Overton said...

Read your entry again. It says "sew" as in mend clothing as opposed to "sow" as in plant crops which aligns more appropriately with "reap" or harvest crops.

Right! And I'm thinking, "so that's why I couldn't find it!," although several dozen sites also used "sew" as well. Just did several new 'Net searches with the preferred spelling, and still couldn't find a confirming Biblical passage.

Fixed for posterity! Thanks....
Dean

4. Tugboat Bertha said...

If you google "As you sow so shall you reap" the explanation of what that statement means and where it can be found in scripture will appear on your screen. (Gal 6:7)

I'm on it!
Dean

5. Paramarine said...

I propose that we mark every utility pole along the Perimeter of the Continental U.S. The country will be one big Eruv with an added benefit of giving the Middle East the impression that we're doing this to flip them the bird. When can we get this project started?

That, sir, instantly goes to the top of the "Best Suggestions of 2008" list! Wickedly funny!
Dean

6. Lulu Head said...

Ray Overton,
You sound like my ex-husband, Richard.

Now now now, Lulu!
Dean

7. David said...

As mentioned, Galatians is not included in the "Jewish" texts of the Bible, but sufficiently similar quotables like "an eye for an eye" or "he who troubleth his own house shall inherit the wind" are.

Regardless, an eruv has a maximum capacity of 599,999 residents. According to the July 20th New York Times, Venice Beach in California is having its own eruv debate (so the debate itself is coast-to-coast even though the eruv is not).

Dean, despite not having an exclusive contract or any privacy clause in my lack of a contract, there are many things I could confirm for you (for a few posts) if I wished to lose my job. Suffice to say, you are spot on regarding many things.

Also, I believe the synagogue-inside-a-house phenomena needs to be termed "a private prayer group." What with the lack of Communism, people can't get in trouble for inviting a bunch of friends to pray in a basement.

- D.G.

Thank you for your comments, David. In respect to the "private prayer group" matter, I believe that "prayer group" was the term used by those who assemble there when this came up in a Village Board meeting this Spring. Yet in the recent un-bylined story in your newspaper, it was referred to as the "Beach Minyan Shul."
Dean

Name
URL
Email
Email address is not published
Remember Me
Comments

CAPTCHA Reload
Write the characters in the image above